Health & Medicine

You are currently browsing the archive for the Health & Medicine category.

I spend a good deal of my time criticizing the media and particularly The Calgary Herald in this blog.  However, every so often, The Herald throws me a curve ball and actually prints a responsible article. Such is the case with the Sunday, July 11, 2010 edition.

In Lessons from my brush with polio, former Calgary Herald writer Catherine Ford gets it right in describing the advances in modern medicine and the snake-oil salesman of the alternative medicine industry. Some highlights of note: Read the rest of this entry »

My Monday, May 17 edition of the Calgary Herald had the following headline listed under TOP NEWS: Largest study suggests cellphone link to cancer risk.

That’s scary. Not true mind you, but scary.

The article written by Sarah Schmidt of Canwest News Service refers to the recently released INTERPHONE study. It plays fast and loose with the truth, but we can’t point fingers at the media alone in this case. The efforts of researchers to suck ever increasing amounts of money from agencies and organizations whose research grant evaluation standards are more about political correctness than scientific merit, can also be blamed here. Read the rest of this entry »

In 1960, the CBC launched the Nature of Things as a half-hour science series. It was a good idea. People wanted to hear about science and the Nature of Things gave it to them. It is currently Canada’s longest running documentary television series.

Notice the word science is gone.

That’s because the Nature of Things is not about science anymore, or at least, not just about science. Now it is equally about the increasingly flaky, pseudo-scientific nonsense promoted by the program’s star, Dr. David Suzuki. I remember when Dr. Suzuki first joined the program 30 years ago. He shattered the image of scientist as nerd and presented science in a way that I thought was magic. Read the rest of this entry »

The Question Is, Who is Defrauding Whom?

CBC National News anchor Peter Mansbridge was filled with the appropriate level of indignation introducing the story of insurance fraud on the April 16, 2010 edition of the National. Unfortunately, the CBC’s pro alternative-medicine bias (examples of which are searchable on this site) placed the CBC in a position where they couldn’t quite get it straight as to who is defrauding whom.

The “investigative journalistic report” came complete with hidden cameras, disguised microphones and undercover journalists posing as customers. In reality, what we got was a public relations exercise posing as journalism. Read the rest of this entry »

New strategy leads to the firing of 12 witch doctors

Naturally the Calgary Herald and its sister paper The Vancouver Sun are outraged. Imagine, the publicly funded Fraser Health Authority actually committing itself to modern medicine and tossing out its staff of witch doctors or spiritual care directors.

Vancouver Sun writer Douglass Todd is leading the charge against this outrage. His biography on the Vancouver Sun website states: Although he was raised in a family of staunch atheists, Douglas Todd has gone on to become one of the most decorated spirituality and ethics writers in North America. (Whew, that was close!)

His piece entitled, Spiritual care directors help keep Canada healthy, was published in the Sunday, January 17 edition of the Calgary Herald.  This seemed to be a follow up piece to Fraser Health’s firing of spiritual-care directors a step backwards, published in the Vancouver Sun on December 21. Read the rest of this entry »

New advertising effort promotes complimentary and alternative therapies.

The Canadian Cancer Society has undertaken a major new fund-raising campaign called Join the Fight complete with a new, very nice website at fightback.ca. The campaign was introduced through a full page ad in the  December 8, 2009 edition of the Calgary Herald. Roughly a third of the ad was dedicated to the work that is being done in the field of complementary and alternative medicine. 

Highlighting research funded by the Canadian Cancer Society, the headline read: Research team explores impact of complementary cancer treatments. The story describes the research of Dr. Marja Verhoef who readers of ASkepticRTN will recall has been involved in all sorts of CAM nonsense including the laughable Integrative Health Institute (now part of Mount Royal University).  Read the rest of this entry »

Television being what it is, it can be rather difficult to research the stories presented. I don’t record the television news and at my age, my memory is a good deal less than perfect.

What I do remember from the Wednesday, December 16 edition of the CBC Television News at 6:00, is someone telling me that acupuncture cures migraine headaches. Not for everyone mind you, but definitely for some people. I remember there was no qualifiers to this. It wasn’t that someone was claiming acupuncture cures migraines. It was a definitive statement by the reporter – acupuncture cures migraines for some people.

It is pure nonsense of course, but I couldn’t help wonder what evidence the reporter had, to substantiate the claim.  I could be wrong in my assessment after all. Perhaps some new research had demonstrated a strong link between acupuncture and pain relief. It would have to be new research, because after twenty years of past research, acupuncture has failed to show positive pain relief much beyond a placebo. Read the rest of this entry »

The medical establishment and politicians must do more to crack down on alternative medicine, argues a senior scientist on the British Medical Journal website.  Thank goodness some medical associations are looking in the mirror and taking on the complimentary and alternative medicine crackpots. <read more ScienceDaily>

An article in published in the Chicago Tribune November 23 entitled Autism treatment: Science hijacked to support alternative therapies, is just too good to miss.  Click on the link to read it now.

Authors Trine Tsouderos and Patricia Callahan, provide a detailed account of how alternative and complimentary medicine practitioners and promoters, including groups such as Defeat Autism Now!, hijack and misuse legitimate scientific findings.  In so doing, they not only provide a good lesson  on the difference between real science, and the pseudo-science of hucksters, but they also give a lesson on what real journalism looks like.

God I wish we had a real newspaper in this city.

The king of quackery promotion comes out against pseudo science!  Meanwhile Alberta Health Services leadership proves it can’t use a calculator (no surprise there).

It was a great day for me. One of those days where everything just comes together.  I sank  in my favorite easy chair, poured myself a very nice Bordeaux that had been hiding in my cellar, and opened up the paper to take in the latest stories of the day. News stories always go better with Bordeaux. But even the wine couldn’t prepare me for what I read on page A13 of today’s Herald.

The king of quackery promotion rails against junk science.

In an opinion piece entitled, Beware of junk science, Gwyn Morgan, former CEO of Encana Corp. rails against junk science. In the article, Mr. Morgan argues persuasively against pesticide paranoia, fears surrounding chemical fertilizer, organic food worship and the borderline hysteria, especially in Europe, of genetically modified foods. Now normally, I would applaud such an effort. Not here though. Read the rest of this entry »

« Older entries